Our body consists of 10-13 trillion cells. As we grow, our body keeps renewing its tissue and cells every 100 days. To renew itself every 100 days, the cell death rate is around 100-130 billion cells every day.
Normal cells grow, replicate and undergo cell death as a way of renewing itself. Cancer cells differ from normal cells in many ways:
- They regulate growth signals themselves.
- They do not respond to growth inhibitory signals.
- They can replicate limitlessly.
- They metastasize or spread to different parts of the body.
Their inability to undergo cell death, is what makes it challenging to treat cancer cells. The two major forms of cell death are: apoptosis and necrosis.
Apoptosis is defined as ‘programmed cell death’ which ensures healthy survival or death balance between cells.
Apoptosis is just one form of cell death. Necrosis is a non specific type of cell death where the cell ruptures and elicits an inflammatory response. Additional cell death mechanisms include autophagy, entosis, paraptosis, and anoikis.
Why apoptosis is chosen as a target for cancer treatment?
Apoptosis is a very well programmed mechanism directed by genes. It is a form of cell death. Its features involve shrinkage of cells, condensation of genetic material, destruction of membrane and other cell organelles.
Apoptosis is one mechanism that is studied in great detail for it dictates the manner of cell proliferation and survival.
It also provides basis for the idea that like other metabolic programs even cell death can disrupted by mutations. This implies that defect in apoptotic pathways can contribute to neurodegenerative (degeneration of the brain) diseases and malignancy.
The idea that apoptosis may play a role in malignancy dates back to 1970s. It was thought that necrosis- a type of cell death which occurs when cell is damaged, was responsible for spontaneously regressing or resolving tumors; but it was found that large percent of cell loss was from apoptosis.
Apoptosis affects tumor initiation, progression and spread to other parts of the body. Normal cells undergo destruction, but do mutations cancer cells remain immortal. Not only immortal they also continue to proliferate.
To metastasize the cancer cell must acquire the ability to survive in the blood stream and invade foreign tissue. Disruption of apoptosis contributes to each of these properties. It can also contribute to drug resistance in cancer.
Since apoptosis consists of precisely regulated events which are generally altered in tumors, apoptosis is chosen over other cell death types as a target for therapy; since each of these programmed apoptotic steps can be manipulated for therapeutic purposes.
What does this mean?
Apoptosis is preferred over other cell death forms as a therapeutic target since it consists of sequential steps that can be modulated in a way that it is relevant to treatment.
Why is there a need of selective apoptosis inducers in cancer treatment?
Anti-cancer agents designed to cause apoptosis in tumor cells, induce apoptosis in normal tissue as well. This contributes to chemotherapy induced toxicity. Thus there is a need to search for selective apoptosis inducers- those that only induce apoptosis in tumor cells.
Variety of signals can induce apoptosis. External triggers include reduction of oxygen, radiation, depletion of survival enabling proteins whereas internal triggers include DNA damage, defects in genes etc.
Targeting apoptosis in cancer treatment can be mediated in following ways:
- Manipulating anti-apoptotic pathways
- Restoring function of pro-apoptotic pathways
- Using death ligands to activate death receptor pathways
- Enhancing the effect of pro-apoptotic mutations
A successful anti-cancer drug is one that kills tumor cells without creating toxicity in normal cells. This mover our attention to natural compounds that can inhibit tumor formation.
In fact diets rich in fruits and vegetables can reduce the risk of cancer. Various plant extracts having chemopreventive potential are being identified.
What does this mean?
A need for selective apoptosis inducers or cell death causing compounds is required so that only tumor cells are killed and normal cells remain unharmed.
How does turmeric redesign cancer cell’s mortality?
Low incidence of cancer is seen in regions where turmeric is consumed as a spice. Turmeric contains a class of compounds which are known as curcuminoids. They are strong antioxidants.
Curcumin is the principal curcuminoid that is identified to have anti-carcinogenic, anti-inflammatory and anti-proliferative property.
In their paper ‘Curcumin and Cancer Cells: How Many Ways Can Curry Kill Tumor Cells Selectively?’ Ravindran et al have discussed how curcumin redesigns and changes the configuration of cancer cells in a way that they become mortal and undergo apoptosis.
Curcumin directly or indirectly controls gene or gene products in cell death pathways and employs multiple methods by which it brings about apoptosis. Since it has multidirectional approach, it reverses drug resistance and cancer cells are unlikely to develop resistance towards curcumin.
The authors of this paper have listed as many as 30 + plus apoptotic pathways that curcumin regulates and demonstrates its therapeutic potential in 30 cancer types.
Another good read on this topic is ‘Modulation of anti-apoptotic and survival pathways by curcumin as a strategy to induce apoptosis in cancer cells‘ by Reuter et al.
We will be going through a few mechanisms by which curcumin redesigns or reprograms cancer cells selectively.
1.Curcumin activates signals within cancer cells to initiate cell death
This apoptotic pathway occurs via the mitochondria- units found inside the cell and are known as powerhouse of the cell. The triggers for this pathway include DNA damage, reduced oxygen levels, loss of cell survival factors etc.
Few of the targets that curcumin manipulates in this pathway include:
- Bcl-2 family of proteins: These proteins support apoptosis or cell death.
- Formation of reactive oxygen species: These compounds cause tissue damage and cell death
- Release of apoptosis inducing factors (AIF)
- Arresting development of cells in between stages of cell cycle
- Restoring function of the p53 protein or tumor suppressor protein
These therapeutic mechanisms of curcumin have been proven to be efficacious in skin cancer, breast cancer, leukaemia, basal cell carcinoma etc.
What does this mean?
Curcumin acts on the intrinsic apoptotic pathway – pathway that depends on internal signals for initiating cell death. It causes production of reactive oxygen species or restores the function of tumor suppressor protein in cancer cells so that they are killed and the cancer regresses.
2. Curcumin acts on external cell death pathways to kill tumor cells
The extrinsic pathway depends on activation of death receptors which are proteins that are expressed on cell surface in a cell that is going to be destroyed. Death ligands are compounds that bind to these receptors, activate them and cause apoptosis.
Here curcumin modulates the following components:
- Induction of death receptors such as Fas receptor, Tumor necrosis factor receptor
- Activation of enzymes known as caspases which play an important role in apoptosis, necrosis and inflammation
- Inhibition of mTOR- an enzyme that regulates cell growth, proliferation and survival
These therapeutic mechanisms of curcumin have been observed in human melanoma, colon cancer, prostate cancer etc.
What does this mean?
Curcumin also acts on external triggers (factors present outside the cells) to stimulate apoptosis and selectively kill cancer cells.
3. Curcumin blocks the activity of cell survival pathways
Two of the major biochemical pathways involved in cell survival are Nuclear factor-kappa B and Akt signalling pathways. Nuclear factor kappa B is an important factor that controls inflammation, cell survival, differentiation and apotosis.
Curcumin suppresses the activity of this factor, arrests cell growth and induces apoptosis. This mechanism has been observed in bladder cancer, breast cancer metastasis, multiple myeloma etc.
The phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase (PI3K/Akt) signaling pathway is also crucial for many aspects of cell growth and survival and is frequently disrupted in human cancers. Activation of factor Akt inhibits apoptosis.
Curcumin is proven to inhibit activation of Akt and act on other targets in this pathway in order to cause apoptosis.
What does this mean?
Apart from regulating cell death pathways, curcumin also works towards inhibiting cell survival pathways so as to sensitize cancer cells towards cell death.
Which are the different targets curcumin modulates to induce apoptosis in cancer cells?
Here is the list of 32 molecular targets that curcumin modulates in order to cause cell death in cancer cells. You can find the details of these mechanisms in Curcumin and Cancer Cells: How Many Ways Can Curry Kill Tumor Cells Selectively?’ .
|1.||Activation of caspase||Caspase are enzymes that are very essential for cell death.|
|2.||Induction of Death Receptor||Death receptors are proteins in biochemical pathways which when activated support cell death|
|3.||Activation of Fas receptor||Fas receptor activates apoptosis signals|
|4.||Increasing activity of p53||p53 is a tumor suppressor protein whose activation inhibits tumor development.|
|5.||Release of Apoptosis Inducing Factor||Apoptosis inducing factors (AIFs) are released from the mitochondria (power house of cell) to stimulate apoptosis.|
|6.||Regulating Cell Cycle||Cell cycle consists of various phases of cell development. Disruption of any one stage can inhibit cell growth.|
|7.||Inhibiting activation of P13K-AKT||Akt is a critical enzyme in bochemical pathways involved in cell proliferation, apoptosis and angiogenesis (blood supply).|
|8.||Inhibition of mTOR||mechanistic target of rapamycin, (mTOR) is a protein that regulates cell growth, cell proliferation, cell survival, autophagy etc.|
|9.||Reducing activity of Androgen Receptors||Androgen receptors are proteins that play an important role in hormone sensitive cancers like prostate cancer.|
|10.||Inhibition of Growth factors and their receptors||Growth factors as the name suggests play an important role in cell survival and development.|
|11.||Inhibition of AMPK||5′ adenosine monophosphate-activated protein kinase is an enzyme that regulates cellular energy balance. Its inactivation can affect proliferation rate.|
|12.||Inhibition of COX and LOX enzymes||COX and LOX are enzymes involved in inflammation and support tumor development.|
|13.||Inhibition of ornithine decarboxylase||Ornithine deacarboxylase is an enzyme that is involved in DNA formation and antioxidant formation. Inhibition of its activity of leads to formation of damaging reactive oxygen species.|
|14.||Inhibition of acidic sphingomylinease||Acidic sphingomylinease is a set of enzymes that is responsible for cell structure maintainence.|
|15.||Inhibition of Phospholipase D||Phospholipase D is an enzyme that protects cells from apoptosis.|
|16.||Inhibition of thioredoxin reductase||Thioredoxin reductase is an enzyme that supports cell growth and survival and its inhibition causes cell death.|
|17.||Inhibiting activation of STAT 3||Mutation of Signal transducer and activator of transcription 3 (STAT3) contributes to inflammation and cancer development.|
|18.||Activating c-Jun Kinase||c-Jun Kinase are a set of enzymes released in cellular stess and play an important role of apoptotic pathway.|
|19.||Induction of DNA fragmentation||Degradation of DNA material disrupts cell survival.|
|20.||Direct DNA damage||Direct DNA damage subsequently leads to cell death.|
|21.||Intracellular calcium ion depletion||Depletion of intracellular calcium ions elicits a signal for apoptosis.|
|22.||Activating mitochondria||Mitochondria is a structure inside that cell that deals with energy balance and is involved in cell differentiation and death.|
|23.||Inhibition of glyoxalase||Glyoxylase is a detoxifying enzyme whose inhibition results in anti-inflammatory and anti-tumor action.|
|24.||Suppressing anti-apoptotic proteins||Inactivating proteins that do not support cell death can sensitize and kill tumor cells.|
|25.||Binding to microtubules||Microtubules, as the name suggests, are tiny tube like structures that maintain cell structure and cell processes. Impairment of their activity can affect cell development.|
|26.||Proteasome Activation||Proteasomes are protein complexes in the cells that degrade damaged proteins and this indirectly plays an important role in cell cycle.|
|27.||Pro/Antioxidant Mechanisms||The balance between prooxidant and antioxidant agents in the cell can be altered to increase sensitivity to cancer treatment.|
|28.||Autophagy||Autophagy is a form of cell death where the cells self destruct and its contents are consumed by cell organelles.|
|29.||Inhibiting Nuclear factor kappa B||Nuclear factor kappa B is a very important protein involved in inflammation, cell differentiation, growth and death.|
|30.||Inhibition of Wnt/beta-catenin Signaling||Wnt/beta-catenin signalling is a pathway that plays an important role in development and regeneration; its activity is impaired in cancer cells.|
|31.||Activation of Nrf2||Nrf2 is a factor that controls the activity of antioxidant enzymes and can positively regulate antioxidant defense.|
|32.||Inhibition of hTERT||TERT is an enzyme that is essential for packaging genetic material of cells and thereby influences cell survival.|
How does curcumin selectively kill tumor cells and not normal cells?
Why curcumin selectively kills tumor cells and not normal cells is not completely understood but researchers have proposed a few reasons:
Absorption of curcumn is higher in tumor cells than normal cells.
The level enzyme glutathione is lower in tumor cells than normal cells which sensitizes them towards curcumin’s anti-cancer activity.
Most tumor cells, but not normal cells, express high levels of nuclear factor-kappaB (protein that serves as master control of cell growth and death) and curcumin suppresses its activity.
In this manner curcumin kills tumor cells and also protects normal cells from toxicity of chemotherapy and radiotherapy.
What does this mean?
Curcumin selectively kills tumor cells only. Normal cells remain unaffected and curcumin protects them from cancer therapy induced toxicity.
Does curcumin exert anti-cancer activity via other cell death forms?
Yes. You would be surprised to know that apoptosis is not the only form of cell death that curcumin induces in cancer cells.
Mitotic catastrophe is a type of cell death that occurs due to errors in cell cycle. Cell cycle is a number of stages through which a cell passes to develop completely. Curcumin induces this type of cell death in breast cancer and esophageal cancer.
What does this mean?
Curcumin destroys cancer cell via cell death forms other than apoptosis.
What are the practical applications of curcumin’s ability to reprogram cancer cells?
Curcumin’s ability to reprogram cancer cells and sensitize them to apoptosis adds to its therapeutic potential as an anti-cancer agent.
TNF -related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL) is a molecule that binds to the death receptors DR4 and DR5 and induces apoptosis in several tumors. Curcumin is found to sensitize chemoresistant ovarian cancer cells, prostate cancer cells and malignant glioma cells.
Curcumin reverses chemoresistance. It also increases the sensitivity to chemotherapeutic agents like Taxol, Vinorelbine, Oxaliplatin, FOLFOX, gemcitabine, paclitaxel and also protects from its toxicity.
What does this mean?
By sensitizing cancer cells to apoptosis, curcumin reverses drug resistance and increases therapeutic efficacy on anti-cancer drugs.
Curcumin has a multifaceted role in cancer treatment. It is pretty fascinating to know that curcumin can reprogram immortal cancer cells and sensitize them towards apoptosis or cell death.
In simple terms curcumin makes tumor cells vulnerable to cancer treatment. Research proves that curcumin manipulates over 20 targets in order to cause apoptosis and this is the reason why cancer cells do not develop resistance towards it.
By re-configuring the cells’ biochemical pathway, curcumin reverses drug resistance, increases sensitivity to chemotherapeutic agents and also serves as chemopreventive (cancer preventing) agent.
Interestingly its reprogramming action is limited only to tumor cells. Curcumin doesn’t affect normal cells; it selectively kills tumor cells and protects normal cells.